UU EVANGELISM: ENCOURAGING THE SECRET STRUGGLE

INVITE RESPONSES TO THE TERM: UU EVANGELISM

Don Rollins


An admittedly tired joke, but bear with me: What do you get when you cross a Jehovah’s Witness with a Unitarian Universalist? Right! Someone standing at your door, wondering what in the heck he/she is doing there!


Thirty years ago, I may have been taking my life into my own hands should I offer a sermon title that included the words Unitarian Universalists and evangelism in the same sentence. Guilt-provoking proselytizers and flint-eyed television preachers would almost surely come the listeners’ minds - pulpit-pounders spinning biblical passages into vivid, certain damnation for all who dared deviate from their version of truth. At best, my liberal religious listeners would have considered today’s sermon title an oxymoron, and about as useful as the proverbial screen door on a submarine!



When evangelism is spoken of in liberal religious circles today, we still have a healthy disdain for anything that smacks of religious arm-twisting; for us, the idea of a faith rooted in anything less than a free and responsible quest for truth is as antithetical in these times as it was when Nixon’s “plumbers” were busy casing the Watergate complex. But fewer and fewer of us are satisfied to state what we oppose and call it good. We’re coming around to the notion that if evangelism is understood to be the process of promoting the basic tenets that hold us together, it’s a good thing.


Thirty years ago, we were barely a decade beyond the merger that gave rise to our admittedly cumbersome name. Furthermore, our Association was still in the business of building new congregations in relatively secluded locales, as well as relocating urban churches and fellowships to the suburbs. It’s not that UUs were unconcerned with growth; I’m hard-pressed to find a time in our history when we no longer cared about witnessing to our values. Truth is, to find some UU congregations one would need a compass and a search light!


So, it’s true that over the last thirty years our Association has taken on a more extroverted face. Call it evolution or call it degeneration, times have changed. We’re more comfortable putting our traditions, values and visions on the religious stage, trusting that in doing so our movement will grow. We’ve become, in our own way, evangelical.


When I hear the term UU evangelism today, it often has to do with how to grow rather than why we want to grow in the first place. Personally, I find this disconcerting - not because I'm opposed to efforts to attract and nurture new members (hardly!) but because when the how is divorced from the why, we might as well be selling vacuum cleaners or encyclopedias.


At the risk of oversimplification, I can think of only two legitimate reasons for liberal religious evangelism: 1. to minister to those whose spiritual journey and values would be enhanced by participation in a UU community; and 2. to build a stronger UU community in the service of those same religious principles and values. Why should we seek to promote our way of religion? Because there are those, who like ourselves, seek a corporate expression of the things they value most in life - a religious community, which at its best, is shot through with tolerance, reason, compassion, laughter and love.


Sticking with my usual homespun approach, some of you might recognize the name, Jeff Foxworthy. He’s a comedian, in the tradition of Minnie Pearl and Grandpa Jones, who uses Southern and Appalachian culture as a springboard for his humor. Foxworthy is most famous for his “You Might Be a Redneck” series, in which he describes certain comical (sometimes stereotypical) traits that might qualify one as a redneck. (Be assured, he does not use the term in its historical, racial context.)



For example (and in jest as we warm up): If, on this Sunday morning,

your body is in a pew/chair but your mind is home reading The New York Times...YOU MIGHT BE A UNITARIAN UNIVERSALIST; If you’ve ever really, really, really wanted to buy that new Honda hybrid...YOU MIGHT BE A UNITARIAN UNIVERSALIST; And, if at least four of the six FM stations on your car radio are tuned to NPR...YOU MIGHT BE A UNITARIAN UNIVERSALIST.


>From former UUA President, John Buehrens:


>Unitarian Universalism is a fierce belief in the way of freedom and reverence for the sacred dignity of each individual. It is cooperation with a universe that that created us; it celebration of life; it is being in love with goodness and justice; it is about having a sense of humor about absolutes...it is respectful of the past, but is not limited to it. It is a trust in growing and a conspiracy with change. It is spiritual responsibility for a moral tomorrow.”


Okay, here we go.


If you experience a connection to nature and other human beings...


If you think you’re responsible for your own mind, body and spirit...


If you know that you don’t know every answer to every question...


If you’re just irreverent enough to get at least a smirk from singer, Tom Waits’ observation that “...there ain’t no devil, that’s just God when he’s drunk”...


If you’re not afraid of humanists, who aren’t afraid of pagans, who aren’t afraid of theists, who aren’t afraid of atheists, who aren't afraid of Hindus, Jews, Muslims, Christians or Buddhists...


If you’re fairly sure that face and body piercing do not, by themselves, signal the end of Western civilization...


If you actually like having your cage rattled and your world rocked...


>From the Persian poet, Saadi:


To worship God is nothing other than to serve the people. It does not need rosaries, prayer carpets or robes. All peoples are members of the same body, created from one essence. If fate brings suffering to one member, the others cannot stay at rest.


If you’d like to scream when you hear the phrases “acceptable losses” and “collateral damage” from those who are waging what the White House calls the “war on terrorism”...


If you’re ashamed at the amount of press coverage given to the debate about the place of God in the Pledge of Allegiance in a nation where one-sixth of the children go to bed hungry and health care is considered non-essential...


If you’re yet to understand why professional athletes garner multi-million dollar contracts while social workers and teachers work two jobs to make ends meet..


If you think the real difference between straight folks and gay folks is that straight folks can publicly express their affection and identity without risking their jobs, homes or safety...


If you believe the only relevant religious community is that which is regularly and measurably involved in efforts for justice and peace...


>From Linda M. Underwood:


All this talk of saving souls. Souls weren’t meant to save, like Sunday cloths that give out at the seams. They’re made for wear; they don’t come with lifetime guarantees.


Don’t save your soul. Pour it out like rain on cracked, parched earth. Give your soul away, or pass it on like a candle flame. Sing it out, or laugh it up the wind.


Souls were meant for hearing broken hearts, for puzzling dreams, remembering August flowers, forgetting hurts.


These men who talk of saving souls! They have the look of bullies who blow out candles before you sing happy birthday, and want the world to be in alphabetical order.


I will spend my soul, playing it out like sticky string into the world, so I can catch every last thing I touch.


If you’re naturally suspicious of those who insist on religion-by-the-numbers and salvation-off-the-rack...


If your scriptures were written by poets, if your saints number hellions as well as heroes, if your church is any place life and love are celebrated...


If you find that words - important as they may be - are, ultimately an insufficient vehicle for expressing the things of the spirit...


If you’ve ever helped someone despite the consequences, trusted someone despite your fears, loved someone in the face of the risks...


>From Stephen Spender (edited):


I think continually of those who were truly great, who from the womb remembered the soul’s history through corridors of light...Whose lovely ambition was that their lips, still touched with fire, should tell of the spirit clothed from head to foot in song.


The names of those who in their lived fought for life, who wore at their hearts the fire’s center. Born of the sun, they traveled a short while towards the sun and left the vivid air signed with their honor.


Borrowing from the African Methodist Episcopal tradition, let’s “call the roll”:


If you’ve ever been inspired by the likes of Benjamin Rush, a physician and signer of the Declaration of Independence, who kept on preaching Universalism even after his home and laboratory were burned to the ground...


If you’re drawn to Michael Servitus, who was burned at the stake rather than renounce his Unitarian beliefs...


If you’re heartened by the story of Margaret Fuller, who championed women’s rights in the face of chronic harassment and threats...


If the names Dickinson, Emerson, Thoreau, Hawthorne, Whitman or Melville line your bookshelves and your heart...


If your heroes include Susan B. Anthony, Theodore Parker, Clara Barton, William Ellery Channing, Jane Addams, John Dewey, or Adlai Stevenson...


Community. Finally, a reading about community - more to the point, about the lack thereof. From The New York Times (August 20, 2002):


Oroville, CA - The Butte County jail cell where Coval Russell spent his last happy days is no bigger than a wheel-chair-size toilet stall, and is cold and dark besides.


No doubt in the two weeks since Russell was removed from the jail, forced back into a world he could no longer abide, his cell has once again become a place no one else would want to spend a single night, let alone the rest of their days. Only he called this place home.


For the year and two months that he spend at the Butte County Jail for stabbing his 70-year-old landlord, he was “Pops”. He was given dibs on the television, allowed to be first in the food line and reserved a place in Monopoly game marathons.


He never had visitors, but he did not need any. Here, among the transient population of men awaiting sentencing or trial, he had found community.


When his body was found Wednesday in the Feather River, where he had fallen from a bridge just a hop from the Motel 6 where he was staying since his release, no one who knew him doubted what happened.


Russell had petitioned the court to keep him in jail indefinitely and had become depressed when a judge, last month, granted him probation and sentenced him to freedom. He said he would kill himself if he was sent “back out there” with no apparent friends and family.


Apparently he did. Witnesses say he took a taxi to the middle of the Table Mountain Bridge...and sat on a rail for half and hour. Then he disappeared.


We delude ourselves when we say that Unitarian Universalism is just about lofty principals; often as not, people seek us out because they simply want a place where they belong. In a world where human beings are regularly marginalized, discounted and ignored may folks are just looking to live a life of integrity.


Our movement is not just about lofty principals, it’s also a one-person-at-a-time religion. A reading from our hymnbook, written by Vivian Pomeroy, suggests that everyone we know is likely in the throes of what she calls the “secret struggle”. For Coval Russell, late of the Butte County Jail, the struggle had to do with holding on to some semblance of community.


Secret struggle. Everybody I know - everybody you know - has a secret struggle. Or two. Or a dozen. This is the why that must precede the how of modern UU evangelism.


I hope that we keep the Coval Russells of this world in mind when we craft our mission statements and plan our growth strategies and draft our budgets - keep them in mind as we quarrel over the relative minutiae of parish life. Keep them in mind in our indefatigable efforts to provide genuine community in a sometimes genuinely hostile world.


UU evangelism. It’s not an oxymoron, but a clear-eyed, heartfelt proclamation of our quest for truth and our vision of community.

Copyright ©2002 by Don Rollins